NCIS: Every Actor Considered for Gibbs Before Mark Harmon

When CBS was putting names on a list for the lead of a new JAG spinoff, Harrison Ford came up more than once. Charles Floyd Johnson, an executive producer on JAG and NCIS, later said Ford "was a name that everybody thought about for Gibbs because he was so perfect." He didn't think it ever got further than a name thrown out.
Quick answer: Before Mark Harmon was offered the part, the NCIS team looked at a long list of well-known actors. They investigated Alec Baldwin, Chris Cooper, Clive Owen, Kevin Bacon, Tom Berenger, Val Kilmer, Charlie Sheen, Aidan Quinn and Patrick Swayze, but they never made those people offers. Scott Glenn was considered seriously and passed. Andrew McCarthy sat down with co-creator Don Bellisario to talk over the role.
A List They Never Called
Casting director Susan Bluestein went through those names in a 20th-anniversary oral history for The Hollywood Reporter. "We did not make offers to those people," she said. "We just investigated."
Chris Cooper is an Oscar winner, for Adaptation. Tom Berenger had been nominated for one, for Platoon. The rest were familiar faces from the movies. It was the kind of list that goes up on a board when a show still has to prove it can exist.
The Ones Who Got Further
Ford stayed in the conversation because he was Ford. Peter Golden, who ran casting at CBS, said that in those early talks, no name was off the table. In the early 2000s, actors of that stature rarely did television, "but that didn't mean you didn't put them on the list." Bluestein, for her part, doesn't remember Ford being discussed at all.
The actor they took more seriously was Scott Glenn. Johnson said he was considered very strongly. Bluestein said there was a lot of discussion, including about whether Glenn might play Ducky instead. Glenn passed. Other people passed on Gibbs too.
Andrew McCarthy got further than a name on a board. Co-creator Don McGill said McCarthy was in the mix at one point, and that he and Bellisario met and talked over the role.
What About Mark Harmon?
Bluestein had Harmon on her list from day one. She had already cast him, in 1991, as John Dillinger in an ABC movie of the week, and she thought he was terrific. "I always felt like Mark really had the gravitas for this character."
Golden remembers her raising the name. Harmon was a big deal, and the assumption in the room was that they would make him an offer, fail to get him, and then work through everyone else. Bluestein said Bellisario wasn't completely sure. He hadn't seen a lot of Harmon's work.
Bellisario has been frank about that hesitation. When he first thought about Harmon for Gibbs, the two words that came to mind were "pretty boy." What changed his mind was Harmon's Emmy-nominated turn as Secret Service agent Simon Donovan on The West Wing in 2002. "What I saw was a very controlled presence, a quiet strength," Bellisario later told Entertainment Weekly. "That's what I was looking for."
Harmon met with Bellisario. They hit it off, and Harmon agreed to do it. Golden said that all of a sudden, the show took on much more importance in his mind.
The First Half-Hour
NCIS didn't start as its own series. It was worked into two episodes of JAG, "Ice Queen" and "Meltdown," which aired on April 22 and April 29, 2003. We wrote about that springboard in Before NCIS: The Forgotten Show That Started It All.
After the two-parter was finished, Johnson said the strength was really the first half-hour, the investigation. "And Mark Harmon just made a big impression." They tested it, and the first half-hour tested so well that then-CBS head Les Moonves asked why they didn't just make the whole show an investigation. That's how NCIS took the shape fans came to know.
The series premiered on September 23, 2003, still carrying the early title Navy NCIS.
Harmon played Gibbs for more than 18 seasons, and he didn't miss an episode until the one where Gibbs refused to board the plane home from Alaska. We counted those episodes in Mark Harmon Never Missed an Episode, Until He Refused to Board the Plane Home.

He is back on screen now as present-day Gibbs in every episode of NCIS: Origins Season 3. In the premiere, Gibbs is shot at that cabin in Alaska.
The list was long. The part went to the actor they weren't sure they could get, and then he said yes.

Leave a Reply